I wanted to write this review carefully. That's because as far as I am concerned this is a great film. There is so much I want to write and I am afraid it will all get lost. So I am going to write this in points.
1. The narrative style, the way the music is put into this film and the cinematography reminds me a lot of Alejandro Gonzales Inarritu's "Babel". Stories switch just like they did in 'Babel'. The pace of the movie is very much like that too. I think the most striking resemblance is that one of the tales of 'Babel' involved Islamic people in backdrops similar to those seen in this movie. I loved 'Babel'. I love this.
2. The music is lovely. I sing "Allah! Allah!" at home all the time. Hey! I know those are the only two words in that song but I like it. The visuals associated with this background song in the movie flash in my mind every time I sing it. Even the two songs the brothers sing at the very beginning of the movie are melodious.
3. Both lead actors have performed. Especially the one who comes under the influence of the 'Maulana'. At the start they made it look like he'd be the hero of the film. Then all of a sudden he's doing all the wrong things! He hardly speaks after he is grown a beard but is lively before that. It maybe the script that gives me a feeling he is acting or it may just be him. Above all is the amazing acting by the 'Maulana'. If this character was not rightly cast and didn't act well the movie would not have been half the movie it is.
4. I like the way the story moves. It's a story of ordinary in today's times. I like that. Right at the start I got a feeling that this is going the traditional Bollywood way. In fact, on hearing good things about this movie I assumed it'd be along the lines of our movies. High on music, high on melodrama, high on exposure and all that has come as expected and accepted today. But this is truly a great movie! The movie starts with two big singers in Pakistan and this lead me to believe it'd be like any of the regular Bollywood stuff. Trust me, I was so surprised and so happy for that. I don't like movies that run too long unless they can really justify the length. 'Khuda Ke Liye' justifies it. Not once was I bored. But the real yardstick for this movie is not the fact that it help my interest, that's not tough as I know the backdrop enough. But it is my wife who is not aware of how terrorists are bred. She was hooked too. This is the winning point. To take a political story and make a movie which can be enjoyed even by people who are not totally into politics. Some movies don't even attempt this, many do and fail. But not this one.
5. Naseer Ud Din Shah's five minutes performance can't be under emphasised. In a movie that is 165 minutes long five minutes can be nothing. But this is something. This is also a good time to mention the characterization in this film. It has a good number of characters. All get introduced in the first half hour or so. Then they keep coming back. It works very well in this movie as we some English, Americans, lots of Pakistanis and a Sikh. All of them very much in the script.
6. Both leading ladies are very pretty. Generally, I would not have mentioned this but I thought I'd do it this time. I liked them both!
RATING: 5/5
Thursday, July 3, 2008
Tuesday, July 1, 2008
Movie Review: Devdas (1955)
This is a oft remade and oft told tale. The references in our lives can't be ignored. All in all this is a movie which will have to carry the burden of impressing viewers even after they know the story. Not many films can carry this burden. Devdas does.
I have known Bimal Roy as the director who lost out. It was just last year when I was reading an article in a newspaper where one of Roy's relations was trying to get people to notice his work. I agree his work has been noticed but that person's argument was that Bimal Roy had never been put on the same pedestal as Guru Dutt and Raj Kapoor. My expectations from this movie were pretty high. Bimal Roy's best is supposedly 'Do Bigha Zameen' but this movie is not concerned less either.
For a storyline that's very simple the length I noticed, before start, was 160 minutes. Quite long I told myself. I braced myself for a slow film. Surprisingly the first 100-120 minutes are quite fast. Obviously, that was great! The movie dipped a little after that for about half an hour after the which the end, which is very very famous, was just a formality. I felt certain portions of the film in that half hour were unnecessarily stretched. Purely my opinion.
If there has ever been a list of best acting performances of all time in Bollywood then Dilip Kumar as Devdas has to be pretty high on that list. This is a super performance. Scene that will stay with me forever: Dilip Kumar is angry but his way of showing anger is very very different. He does not shout yet we know he is angry and will lose control any second. The scar on Suchitra Sen is the result of his anger.
I also liked the idea that Paro is the brave one and Devdas the coward. She makes her way to his room at two in the morning and tells him she loves him. Simply brillaint! I can't remember a better scene in cinema at the moment. The scene just before this one, where she tells her friend of her plan to tell Devdas, set the tone for her character.
However, I didn't understand why Devdas chooses to drink himself to death in a train. I think I missed something there. Was I supposed to feel that train was taking him to his death? Or was there something else there?
RATING: 3.5/5
I have known Bimal Roy as the director who lost out. It was just last year when I was reading an article in a newspaper where one of Roy's relations was trying to get people to notice his work. I agree his work has been noticed but that person's argument was that Bimal Roy had never been put on the same pedestal as Guru Dutt and Raj Kapoor. My expectations from this movie were pretty high. Bimal Roy's best is supposedly 'Do Bigha Zameen' but this movie is not concerned less either.
For a storyline that's very simple the length I noticed, before start, was 160 minutes. Quite long I told myself. I braced myself for a slow film. Surprisingly the first 100-120 minutes are quite fast. Obviously, that was great! The movie dipped a little after that for about half an hour after the which the end, which is very very famous, was just a formality. I felt certain portions of the film in that half hour were unnecessarily stretched. Purely my opinion.
If there has ever been a list of best acting performances of all time in Bollywood then Dilip Kumar as Devdas has to be pretty high on that list. This is a super performance. Scene that will stay with me forever: Dilip Kumar is angry but his way of showing anger is very very different. He does not shout yet we know he is angry and will lose control any second. The scar on Suchitra Sen is the result of his anger.
I also liked the idea that Paro is the brave one and Devdas the coward. She makes her way to his room at two in the morning and tells him she loves him. Simply brillaint! I can't remember a better scene in cinema at the moment. The scene just before this one, where she tells her friend of her plan to tell Devdas, set the tone for her character.
However, I didn't understand why Devdas chooses to drink himself to death in a train. I think I missed something there. Was I supposed to feel that train was taking him to his death? Or was there something else there?
RATING: 3.5/5
Sunday, June 29, 2008
Movie Review: Guru Shishyaru
I have seen some old Kannada movies which are very very good. 'Yeradu Kanasu' and 'Gowri Ganesha'. Unfortunately, this is bad.
If the story of them movie were to be put in two sentences it'd sound promising. That perhaps is the only decent deal in this movie. The outline story is not bad. I'd even go a step further to state that any other treatment of the movie would have to be better. The film is so amateurish! What's wrong with this movie?
1. Scenes don't flow smoothly from one scene to the other. A song ends and the next scene is in the middle of a jungle with horses running around.
2. The acting can't get worse than this. How can the 'shishyas' think they are funny? The supposedly comical scenes are too long. Their voices are more irritating than funny.
3. The gags designed in this movie are pathetic. The sequence where the 'shishyas' drive away the thieves is unbearable.
4. It actually put me to sleep. I slept sometime after the seventy-fifth minute only to wake up around the hundredth minute to realize nothing had changed.
RATING: 1/5
If the story of them movie were to be put in two sentences it'd sound promising. That perhaps is the only decent deal in this movie. The outline story is not bad. I'd even go a step further to state that any other treatment of the movie would have to be better. The film is so amateurish! What's wrong with this movie?
1. Scenes don't flow smoothly from one scene to the other. A song ends and the next scene is in the middle of a jungle with horses running around.
2. The acting can't get worse than this. How can the 'shishyas' think they are funny? The supposedly comical scenes are too long. Their voices are more irritating than funny.
3. The gags designed in this movie are pathetic. The sequence where the 'shishyas' drive away the thieves is unbearable.
4. It actually put me to sleep. I slept sometime after the seventy-fifth minute only to wake up around the hundredth minute to realize nothing had changed.
RATING: 1/5
Movie Review: Harold & Kumar Go to White Castle
The only positive I saw in this movie was the acting performance of the lead actors. Very surprising to see the two deliver some nonsensical lines with sheer dedication and sincerity.
I hardly found anything funny. Perhaps it was because I missed any references, if there were any.
Surprisingly, my wife was laughing all the time! I felt it was a movie guys sit together and watch but it was my wife who laughed all the way.
RATING: 1/5
I hardly found anything funny. Perhaps it was because I missed any references, if there were any.
Surprisingly, my wife was laughing all the time! I felt it was a movie guys sit together and watch but it was my wife who laughed all the way.
RATING: 1/5
Saturday, June 28, 2008
Movie Review: Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Tim Burton is truly different. My list of favorites is endless. It is hard to keep the list limited when one enjoys all genre of cinema.Tim Burton has a gift. He can transport people into a land of magic. All his movies are visually stunning. Among filmmakers he knows the power of colors. Bright colors on a dark backdrop. Spotless white gowns, lush green grass and spiraling red blood. He is the one who can capture them best on film.
Now I have seen the original as a kid. Fortunately, I didn't remember the end of the original movie. So effectively I was watching it for the first time. In short, the story is nothing much to write home about. It is a one line tale which spans a while. Writing a word on it will leave nothing for the viewers who look for a story. It is all about the visual treatment. The gags to lure the boys and girls. The song and dance routine. However, there is one important additional aspect. Johnny Depp.
Johnny Depp comes in after the first thirty five minutes. After that it is a one man show. His screen presence can't be described in my reviews. Only seeing can be believing here. It is a crazy character that Depp sets to portray in this film. Wonka's character is a focal point to taking the audience from the ordinary life we live to the magic that happens that happens in the chocolate factory. Depp's performance is crucial and does he deliver! I will never fathom why actors give such wonderful in movies like these. They know it all along that an Oscar or any major award is not coming their way. But they give it their 100%.
Freddie Highmore does perform. However, it is the two girls, Ms. Robb and Ms. Winter, if I am not mistaken who put on a surprisingly good show.
But all said and done it is Tim Burton all the way. If there is one director who stamps his mark on every frame it is Tim Burton. I am sure anyone could identify a Burton film with his eyes open for two minutes. The colors, the shades, the costumes and the make up are beautiful. But that is nothing new. All his movies are like that.
CONCLUSIONS: A simple story, with imaginative visuals and Johnny Depp make for a wonderful matinee.
RATING: 3/5
Now I have seen the original as a kid. Fortunately, I didn't remember the end of the original movie. So effectively I was watching it for the first time. In short, the story is nothing much to write home about. It is a one line tale which spans a while. Writing a word on it will leave nothing for the viewers who look for a story. It is all about the visual treatment. The gags to lure the boys and girls. The song and dance routine. However, there is one important additional aspect. Johnny Depp.
Johnny Depp comes in after the first thirty five minutes. After that it is a one man show. His screen presence can't be described in my reviews. Only seeing can be believing here. It is a crazy character that Depp sets to portray in this film. Wonka's character is a focal point to taking the audience from the ordinary life we live to the magic that happens that happens in the chocolate factory. Depp's performance is crucial and does he deliver! I will never fathom why actors give such wonderful in movies like these. They know it all along that an Oscar or any major award is not coming their way. But they give it their 100%.
Freddie Highmore does perform. However, it is the two girls, Ms. Robb and Ms. Winter, if I am not mistaken who put on a surprisingly good show.
But all said and done it is Tim Burton all the way. If there is one director who stamps his mark on every frame it is Tim Burton. I am sure anyone could identify a Burton film with his eyes open for two minutes. The colors, the shades, the costumes and the make up are beautiful. But that is nothing new. All his movies are like that.
CONCLUSIONS: A simple story, with imaginative visuals and Johnny Depp make for a wonderful matinee.
RATING: 3/5
Wednesday, June 25, 2008
Movie Review: Abhimaan
The late Hrishikesh Mukherjee has made some of the most distinct movies in Bollywood. There was no flamboyance in his cinema. It relied heavily on a story. I love such films.
Now this great director made two types of movies. Comedies and drama. Two totally different genres. Not many directors can handle both. 'Abhimaan' clearly is drama.
Instead of a full fledged review I will try to recollect some scenes that 'worked' and 'didn't work' for me.
1. The opening scene, with the best song of the film, works perfectly in setting up the character of Subir. Loves his success more than the money. After he does not need to, he has Chandru to take care of that aspect.
2. The prophecy of the great classical singer did give away the story. Having known the story beforehand I won't comment.
3. The most memorable scene is the one where Chandru returns to take Subir to his village. Chandru tells him about the child. But Subir is clear, he just won't go. It is a powerful scene with the dialogues spoken with a close up of Amitabh's face.
4. Uma losing all faith in life was not a bad idea for this movie. I generally feel that such 'tricks' help stretch the film beyond the customary 120 minutes and help in the addition of songs. However, here it was facilitated to get both Uma and Subir singing again.
My personal favourties of this great director are "Namak Haraam" & "Aashirwaad". In my books 'Abhimaan' will be second to them.
Rating: 3/5
Now this great director made two types of movies. Comedies and drama. Two totally different genres. Not many directors can handle both. 'Abhimaan' clearly is drama.
Instead of a full fledged review I will try to recollect some scenes that 'worked' and 'didn't work' for me.
1. The opening scene, with the best song of the film, works perfectly in setting up the character of Subir. Loves his success more than the money. After he does not need to, he has Chandru to take care of that aspect.
2. The prophecy of the great classical singer did give away the story. Having known the story beforehand I won't comment.
3. The most memorable scene is the one where Chandru returns to take Subir to his village. Chandru tells him about the child. But Subir is clear, he just won't go. It is a powerful scene with the dialogues spoken with a close up of Amitabh's face.
4. Uma losing all faith in life was not a bad idea for this movie. I generally feel that such 'tricks' help stretch the film beyond the customary 120 minutes and help in the addition of songs. However, here it was facilitated to get both Uma and Subir singing again.
My personal favourties of this great director are "Namak Haraam" & "Aashirwaad". In my books 'Abhimaan' will be second to them.
Rating: 3/5
Movie Review: The Bicycle Thief
The title is more than apt. I should have seen the end coming about half an hour into the movie. At that point I was asking myself why this movie was named so. After all they were not speaking of the thief at all. It was the story of a father and son searching for a stolen bicycle. I should have seen it coming.
It is a simple film. No doubts about that. On the surface it is a very simple tale. Hardly touching. I mean, what's the big deal about a guy stealing a cycle to replace one that was stolen from him? When the end credits rolled I started thinking, what made this movie a classic? I decided look at some points not highlighted in the film to draw some deeper meaning.
1. Santona was one character referred to twice. As an Indian and having some belief in the powers of the psychic I thought of this. Ricci loses the cycle a day after not paying Santona. After all his wife had almost 'bought' Ricci a job but failed to pay. Later when he visits her again as a last resort. She tells him that this morning is his last chance to find it failing which he shall never succeed in tracing it. Ricci sees the guy who has stolen the cycle. In my opinion a point the movie was trying to make was the power of Santona. If Riicci chose to press charges he'd probably have nailed the guy. But he either didn't believe in the prophecy or lost confidence in himself.
2. On the other hand, the film might have been trying to say that some things are meant to be. Maybe that job was not in Ricci's fate. Maybe his family were to live in poverty. Maybe he is not meant to be a 'bicycle thief'. Maybe the thief who stole Ricci's bicycle was meant to get away.
Finally, I could not understand the church angle or why the link of the old man. However, they did make interesting viewing.
RATING: 3.5/5
It is a simple film. No doubts about that. On the surface it is a very simple tale. Hardly touching. I mean, what's the big deal about a guy stealing a cycle to replace one that was stolen from him? When the end credits rolled I started thinking, what made this movie a classic? I decided look at some points not highlighted in the film to draw some deeper meaning.
1. Santona was one character referred to twice. As an Indian and having some belief in the powers of the psychic I thought of this. Ricci loses the cycle a day after not paying Santona. After all his wife had almost 'bought' Ricci a job but failed to pay. Later when he visits her again as a last resort. She tells him that this morning is his last chance to find it failing which he shall never succeed in tracing it. Ricci sees the guy who has stolen the cycle. In my opinion a point the movie was trying to make was the power of Santona. If Riicci chose to press charges he'd probably have nailed the guy. But he either didn't believe in the prophecy or lost confidence in himself.
2. On the other hand, the film might have been trying to say that some things are meant to be. Maybe that job was not in Ricci's fate. Maybe his family were to live in poverty. Maybe he is not meant to be a 'bicycle thief'. Maybe the thief who stole Ricci's bicycle was meant to get away.
Finally, I could not understand the church angle or why the link of the old man. However, they did make interesting viewing.
RATING: 3.5/5
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)