Wednesday, August 27, 2008

Movie Review: Plan 9 from Outer Space

The worst movie ever? I don't think so.

  1. Minutes 1-25: The movie has been decently set-up in terms of story. The acting and production qualities are very very mediocre. But after Tim Burton's 'Ed Wood' I expect this. Burton's film also emphasises that Edward D. Wood, Jr. was not bothered about trivial stuff and wanted to focus on the 'big picture'. I am looking for that in this film.
  2. Minutes 26-53: Worst movie ever? I can't believe there is no movie worse than this. Wait! There are so many. Most Bollywood movies of the 1990s would be lesser than ''Plan 9...''. 'Ghajini' is another. So far the film has not been a masterpiece. But it definitely has not been the worst. The plot though silly does keep moving along, at times quick and most times slow.
  3. Last Twenty-five Minutes: Clearly this is as good as the first first twenty-five minutes. I liked it! There is some genuinely engaging conversation about the usage of arms. For once a movie involving extra-terrestrials has some purpose.

I like it more than I like 'Independence Day' and I am not scared to say so.

RATING: 3/5

Book Review: Shame

EXPECTATIONS:

It was raining like it does during that season in Mumbai. The disastrous rainfall, now a part of history, was a week away. But this write-up is not about that eventful day. A week before that on the way to campus I bought 'Shalimar the Clown' off the street. For long I was wanting to read the work of an Indian writer. First attempt at reading 'Shalimar the Clown' was a failure. Honestly, I could not understand it. Second attempt, within a week, met with the same result. The next time I was home my 'chikkappa' and my father totally wrote off Salman Rushdie. They claimed he is a hypocrite, they still do, and I didn't understand what that had to do with his writing. My chikkappa said he tried reading 'Midnight's Children' and could not finish it. However, he didn't give me a reason for not reading it fully. I didn't want to make any guesses. Then and there, Salman Rushdie was not an author on my list of must-reads. I felt he wrote books for people with intellect beyond mine. Within my mind I surrendered to reading regular fiction consisting of bestsellers.
'One Hundred Years of Solitude' changed my perception of novels. Arguably the author's most well-known book was to me highly entertaining. Yes, there are references to the war in Colombia and maybe lots of other stuff but to me it was great entertainment. A work by a Nobel prize winner became one of my favorites. It was time to revisit an Indian author and maybe go beyond the bestsellers.
An ideal start would have been 'Midnight's Children' but I could not get it. The library at UCD has everything related to this novel except the novel itself, books on understanding the book, stage play written from the novel, commentary on this etc. 'The Satanic Verses' was checked out. I was not too familiar with the other books. So why did I pick 'Shame'? I read somewhere on the internet Rushdie saying something about getting a better book after winning the Booker prize for 'Midnight's Children'. If not exactly at least something of this sort said by Rushdie himself gave me a feeling it was a good book. I also vaguely remembered it was on the Booker nominations, but I was not sure then. I gambled with 'Shame' and checked it out on my I-card.
On coming home I looked for response on the internet. What did I find?
  1. For many books Wikipedia has a long article which includes plot, characters, response, etc. But for this there was hardly anything. I was dissappointed.
  2. I could hardly find any reviews on the internet. Another disappointment.

The arguments in favor and against the book were balanced, 2-2. I started the book not knowing what to expect. I was starting with a clean slate. The thing hurting me was a feeling that I was starting with one of his 'lesser' books and that if I didn't like this I may not read Salman Rushdie's works again.

AS I READ THE BOOK:

  1. PAGES 1-40: I could not believe what I was reading! I was blown away in the first forty pages. I was reading almost every paragraph twice. Yes, I had trouble following the book. Why? The sentence structure was too complicated. So many ideas being brought about in the same sentence that I had to read them more than once and put the different ideas together. I loved it because it was unlike what I expected. The story until then was so out-of-the-world. It was truly fantastic. Three sisters, their father's death, their party to get pregnant and the way they bring up Omar Khayyam Shakil. It was so captivating. At this stage I looked closer into the article in Wikipedia and noticed it had 'magic-realism'. I loved this in 'One Hundred Years of Solitude' and was thrilled to see it here.
  2. PAGES 41-200: The best portion of the book in my opinion. The strong but strange characterization of Omar Khayyam Shakil, Maulana Dawood, the Harappas, the Hyders, the women in the Harappa and Hyder families, the policeman who marries (shamelessly) Hyder's younger daughter (is it his daughter?), Sufiya Zinobia and an endless list of supporting characters. At this stage I started to feel that for a 286-page novel there are too many characters. In fact there are too many characters anyway (just like 'One Hundred Years of Solitude'). To have so many characters, who all need introductions, the pace does not slack. Surprising isn't it? 'One Hundred Years of Solitude' too employs a similar technique of jumping back and forth in time sometimes through its characters and sometimes through the narrative. Somewhere in this period I again visited Wikipedia and came to know it is the story of General Mohd. Zia-ul-haq and Zulfikar Ali Bhutto of whom I didn't know much. All fears of not knowing the history evaporated as I flipped page after page.
  3. LAST PAGES: With some forty-odd pages to go I could not wait to see how it'd end. I loved the 'eighteen shawls' Rani Harappa makes for Arjuman Harappa. The detail with which Iskander's life is brought out is memorable because I could visualize the shawls in my head. Moving on, I should have seen the end coming. I should have known it would culminate in 'Nishapur'. The 'magic realism' keeps building up as the reader turns the pages. The end is so far-fetched even for 'magic realism'. But by then I was totally into Rushdie's grip. I was ready to believe anything. Sufiya Zinobia's transformation into the animal and the trio escaping dressed as women only to be taken right into their graves is over-dramatic but I lapped it up.
  4. The similarity of Babar Shakil's death and that of one of the characters in 'One Hundred Years of Solitude' can't be ignored. Both turn into angels and take off.

RANDOM THOUGHTS:

  1. Rushdie is a part of 'Shame'. He surfaces now and then in the book. I don't remember specifics of these and so can't elaborate. However, I will say that at first I was surprised with this 'trick'. It seemed at first a way for the author to impose himself on the reader. Made me feel Salman Rushdie was being arrogant here. But as I kept reading I found myself looking forward to these parts of the book. They gave better insights of his opinions on various issues (agree or disagree is up to the reader) and some places exposed me to other great works of literature. I love this totally new technique which I have not come across in any book I have read. Now I don't care if Rushdie was imposing himself or is arrogant.
  2. Wikipedia claimed this is the story of General Mod. Zia-ul-haq and Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. Any other book would have been written around these two characters. 'Shame' does not do that. Omar Khayyam Shakil is numerous times referred to as the 'peripheral hero' and the book starts and finishes with him. I don't know why Salman Rushdie does this. When I closed this book did I think of any one characters or two characters or three or four? I simply thought of the book as an outrageous but engrossing tall-tale. Rushdie calles Omar the 'peripheral hero' but in my opinion he is not. If anyone it is the narrator who simply takes us through all the significant happenings in Omar's lifetime which includes those two important people in history. That's one great thing about this, the way these important characters are placed in the book. Not at the start, not at the end, not in the middle but scattered everywhere and surfacing now and then.
  3. All the while I was reading 'Shame' I kept telling myself it was the best book I'd ever read. It was so much fun. Not a thriller but I didn't want to put the book down. Only when I finished it did I tell myself to be a little impartial. A day later I realized that in literature and cinema (and in majority fields) there is no such thing as 'best' and that any such title bestowed is purely a matter of opinion. So it is not the best book. But I want to put it down here because, and I quote myself, "all the while I was reading 'Shame' I kept telling myself it was the best book I'd ever read'. I am going to read every book by Salman Rushdie.

WHAT 'SHAME' & 'ONE HUNDRED YEARS OF SOLITUDE' HAVE DONE FOR ME:

Starting today I shall read as many award winning books as possible. Very consciously I shall approach popular books from now. Reading 'Shame' & 'One Hundred Years of Solitude' have put the belief of enjoying, if not with complete understanding, the act of reading prize winning books.

Monday, August 18, 2008

The Kite Runner

When I read this book last month it left two sentences in my memory.
  1. For you, a thousand times over,
  2. There is a way to be good again.
Without any doubt I can say that the kid playing Hassan, Ahmad Khan Mahmoodzada, is the best casting I have come across in a long long time. This kid has the innocent looks of Hassan from the novel.That's not all, Ahmad is a wonderful wonderful actor. The best part of this film is Ahmad's performance. Just watch his face as he innocently asks Amir why the protaganist in his first short story does not just smell onions to produce tears. Better just observe how his face and gait as he walks out after being abused. The book had me feeling sorry for Hassan right through but that's was just because it was written that way. I feel for Hassan and only Hassan in this film and it solely due to Ahmad. Only a good director can extract such a performance from a boy so young. Kudos to Ahmad and Marc Foster.

This film is another exercise in the discovering that the novel is almost always better than the film. Exceptions of course will be all of Kubrick's films who made movies out of books that will not be known in this day and age, and Coppola's 'The Godfather'. My wife's words sum up the feelings for someone who has read the book.

"The book is so emotional. We feel like crying at many points but the movie does not give out any such feelings."

In my opinion, there was little more that could have been done. If one were to watch the film not having read the book it may actually seem very good. Keep this in mind I rate the film as I do.

RATING: 3.5/5

Wednesday, August 13, 2008

Movies Cast in the Same Mould: 'Hellboy'

I just noticed that the Hellboy movies have the same skeleton. Underneath the action and the wonderful creatures, which I call the flesh, they are the same can I say skeleton.

1. Both movies open with a scene that happened a long time ago. In the first installment it is the one where the the hero, the superhero rather, and the villain are introduced. In the latter a flashback is employed but the purpose is the same. The viewers get to see Hellboy and the villain at the same time.

2. Within these opening scenes also there is a pattern. The superhero is shown is shown as a kid while the villain is already grown up or from the past. This I feel gives an effect of the villain already set into his evil ways while Hellboy is still an innocent kid.

3. The first action scenes involving Hellboy and the team from the bureau are in similar places, places which have relics and antiques. In the sequel it is an auction house where antiques are sold while in the first film it is a museum. I have seen both films just once and even the rooms looked similar to me.

4. Hellboy must not show himself in public and he just has to do it. In both the movies this happens at nearly the same time, during or after a fight sequence.

5. Somewhere in both movies Hellboy saves a kid (or kitten) while the mother (or owner) can be heard screaming in the backdrop. Hellboy continues fighting holding the kid (or kitten) and saves the day. The only difference being that in the second part he is blamed for his action.

6. The villains make their way into BPRD to either kill or abduct someone. This happens just before the final act which involves Hellboy having to go to some creepy place.

7. Oh yeah! The final acts in both the films involve Hellboy going somewhere. The only difference is that in the first part he has to get his revenge while in the second part he has to help Abe.

8. The last act in both films is a let-down. The creature from hell never looks threatening in the first part and the Golden Army hardly has any screen time to scare. It appeared that movies were finished in a hurry if not made in a hurry.

THERE IS ONE DIFFERENCE: The second film actually takes some time to set-up the future movies.

However, I did like the "Hellboy 2: The Golden Army". At least, it was not too bad.

Sunday, August 10, 2008

Movie Review: Scenes from a Marriage

A friend told me about him last year and soon after that I read of his demise in the papers. It made front page news in India. I was expecting a great movie. Let's look at what I got;

1. The title for this movie is very apt. This film is a series of scenes put together. But the scenes are not just randomly picked up. They do take the story forward. Essentially, this is the first time I have seen a movie with this concept. Scenes are introduced with titles and play for around a half-hour and then we move to another scene. The scenes independently make intriguing viewing and as a whole form a part of a greater story.

2. I was talking about close-ups of facial expressions in the film 'Blue' and how I was not able to understand what the character was feeling on many occasions. It is very similar in this film where almost every scene is indoors and all dialog happens with close-up shots of the actors. In this film there is a lot of dialog which works well with me. This helps me understand the character and gauge the acting.

3. If there ever is a brilliant pair on screen portraying a couple it has to be these two. Now I use superlatives very often but I mean it from my heart this time. Very rarely will we see performances as real as this. Erland Josephson and Lic Ullman are so believable. I don't want to elaborate on this because the only point I want to highlight is the reality of their acting.

4. One point I have to state about this story. I truly loved this aspect of the film. After Johan leaves for Paris I could not imagine he'd actually get closer to Mariane than he ever was before. Stereotypes often portray hatred, or at least lost warmth, among a couple who have had to face the consequences of a broken marriage. But through this film I realize that adults can't obviously act like kids and not speak at all. That's why when Johan comes home after a few years I was not surprised by their behaviour. They are trying to break the ice and see how it goes from there. That's how adults would probably tackle the situation.

5. I will not forget the scene where Johan tells his wife that he is leaving. I truly don't have words to describe this scene so I won't even try. But the credit has to be shared between the acting, the dialog and the direction. The only point I must add is a repetition, the scene is handled with total originality and not like other commercial ventures.

6. The last two scenes are the only ones where the dialog got very heavy for me. There seemed to be deeper meanings which I didn't decipher.

Surprisingly, this is the freshest film on marital life that I have seen. Although it was made 34 years ago it does not seem dated.

RATING: 4/5

Wednesday, August 6, 2008

Movie Review: The Dark Knight

My reviews generally open with expectations. What can I say about my expectations with this film? Saying they were as tall as the mile high buildings in Gotham city would still remain an understatement. Let's get to the points:

STORY:

1. 'The Dark Knight' has a very linear story. It does not even have flashbacks. Very surprising as I associate Nolan with complex highly nonlinear plots. In fact, this tactic was very useful in converting even average tales into gripping cinema, like 'Memento' and 'The Prestige' which in my opinion would have been lesser movies if not for the style of narration. I do not mean to say that 'The Dark Knight' is lesser for having a linear screenplay.

2. I am surprised that no one has felt the story is overdone. It is very very complex. No one can possibly give away this movie's story in any review. Luckily, it is followable and very very thrilling.

3. This is an obvious one. There is no explanation for Joker being the way he is. I didn't expect this. In any other movie there would have been a flashback or some other means to convince the viewers of his actions and his being. 'The Dark Knight' does not try to do that. For movie that's 152 minutes that works so well without this to have this would have been foolhardy. Not a single film by Nolan gives a feeling that some scene is forced into the movie. The way the script works, it keeps going forward in time, it would have been reckless to take the clock back to include an unnecessary flashback. Joker's intentions have to be accepted by the viewer with a no-questions-asked policy and I did just that.

4. This is perhaps the best part of the film for me. This is one film where the villain's plotting is not shown explicitly. Even the execution of the Joker's plans is not shown. The audience sees his actions through the cops, Dent and Batman. What an effect this has! This is a great great idea. Why? Every action comes as a total surprise. Some of 'stunts' that he pulls off make me feel as he has some magical powers. How does a guy get to perform that "social experiment" or place Dawes and Dent where they are? Without showing how Joker works but showing only what he does Nolan convinces a simpleton like me that Joker can do whatever he wants. So when Joker has the entire city under his control through the T.V. telecast or announces that he will kill Reese in 60 minutes I am convinced that Joker can actually do whatever he says. This is the trick of Nolan along with Ledger's performance make Joker as menacing as he comes out in this film.

5.The motive behind Harvey Dent's transformation into Two-Face is hackneyed. I can't believe Nolan could not come up with a better reason for Dent to lose control. Losing a girl-friend is reason enough for men to lose their mind, especially she accepts his proposal a split-second before her demise, but it is an oft-used concept to explain villainy.

6. Dent's reason for transformation is Rachel's death. The idea of doing with her character is a total surprise. This along with no explanation of Joker's past are fresh ideas in this superhero flick. Which other superhero loses his girl?

7. 'Social experiment'! Brilliant! I loved this small thing in the film. Joker's goal is to prove that Batman lives in an indecent world and Batman has no reason to fight for the people of Gotham. The script had to be written in a way to prove Joker wrong. Once this experiment goes wrong Joker is stunned.

8. Within that experiment I didn't like the way the experiment fails. I guess the way it is done is good for dramatization but I everyone will see that coming. I am trying to see how else this could have been done. Let's see.......I can't think of any other way. Can someone else? Maybe there is no better way. I should not have brought this up but I am leaving it on print anyway just because I felt it was predictable.

ACTING:

1. There has been a lot of talk with regard to the acting in this film. I maintain that there will be no awards, maybe except for Heath Ledger, but the entire does maintain a straight face throughout. Unlike other comic book movies there is no one smiling at the camera or giving us a feeling they are bored. Every actor knows where he or she fits in the script and acts with a purpose. I picked this point from another review and it's here because this is point readers to keep in mind when I explain 'why this movie works' later on.

2. The reaction to Heath Ledger's performance has been unanimous. I fully endorse the fact that he has given us one of the best villains of all time. It will be hard to forget this performance especially in the aftermath of his demise. Will he win a posthumous Oscar? It is too early to say. The Oscars are far away and there is every chance of another better performance. If not a better performance there is an even better chance of performance which if not as good as this but comes in a film which hits the screen very close to the Oscars.

RANDOM THOUGHTS:

1. "The Dark Knight" is more about the story. Characterization takes a bit of a backseat in this film. If there is any characterization it is seen in Harvey Dent and to some extent in James Gordon. Personally, I feel there is no characterization of Joker. He is just what he is from his first scene to his final scene. The character does not change. It is one-dimensional. Some will argue that the character of Batman and Joker are contrasts and that is great in itself. But the characters don't grow. Harvey Dent character grows (rather deteriorates!) in this film.

2. This may contradict something I wrote earlier. But I will try to push it through anyway. The discussion here is about the final act of the film, the portion of the film after Joker blasts his way out of prison and then the hospital. Until this point the movie is very very real. The portion after this when Joker has the entire city at his disposal is where the film slips a little away from reality. I don't see it happening in today's day and age when one man will hold a city, that too as big as Gotham, hostage. But I once again emphasize that I was so caught up in the film that I believed it all. I still do. It is only as I write this do I feel it is not possible.

3. I didn't like the bit where the batmobile comes in the way of a shot fired from a rocket launcher. I mean that's the one scene, during the film, where I was reminded that is a comic book we are talking about.

4. "Batman Begins" achieves one thing that 'The Dark Knight' does not. The former speaks more about the system at Gotham which is inherently screwed. It has been so for long. This feels very real. In the latest installment I got a feeling that Joker was trying his best to make the system worse. He is externally corrupting the system. As a result, Batman is fighting a bad system in the first film and fighting a criminal in the latter. To me the concept of the first film is more appealing. But they are different films and both are great.

5. I see Christopher Nolan getting at least a nomination for direction. The Nolan brothers will receive nominations for writing. These two I am dead sure about. In fact, I feel this film can win these categories. I am little skeptical about nominations for best picture and one for Heath Ledger. The chances are high in my opinion, I am not ruling it out, but no one can state this for sure.

QESTION: WHY THIS MOVIE WORKS?

ANSWER: This is where my views may hurt the ones who call themselves "true" fans. 'Batman Begins' and 'The Dark Knight' do not work as films inspired from comics. They work as stand-alone films. Only 'Sin City', a very good film, constantly reminds viewers that they are watching a comic book adaptation. All the Nolans have done is take the characters from the comics and put them into the real world.For a long time I have been hearing from friends and relations that to enjoy an 'x' superhero movie one has to understand the character that was developed in the comic. Nolan's two films have shown how people like the ones I mentioned have been hiding behind this excuse to make a series of badly adapted superhero films look good. For many years I have been hearing that some 'x' movie is the best superhero film till date. That is not so with these two flicks. We are ready to put them alongside real cinema. Critics have been saying this maybe one of the best crime movies of all time. Some critic went even further and spoke of 'The Departed' and 'Heat' in the same breath. When a superhero film is spoken of as a great crime film it can no longer be considered as a superhero film. Not too long ago Ang Lee tried to make 'The Hulk' into such a film which failed at the B.O. and with critics. Most importantly, 'The Hulk' failed to get a favorable review from me! Nolan has succeeded where 'The Hulk' failed. I don't know a single person who has read the 'Sin City' comics. Note that reading the comics after viewing the film does not count.

CONCLUSION:

1. Watch it once because it exceeds all expectations.

2. Watch it twice as a triumph of the Nolans.

3. Watch it the thrice for a great super-hero film.

4. Watch it again for it rises above a suerhero film into one of film noir.

5. Watch it once again for it will be the fastest 152 minutes of your life.

6. Watch it the penultimate time because it is my favorite of 2008.

7. Finally, watch it because it is a must-watch.

I pray the Nolans have at least another two dozen movies left in them. At least a couple of them being Batman films.

RATING: 5/5

Tuesday, August 5, 2008

Movie Review: Barry Lyndon

Stanley Kubrick. What name! What movies! Almost every single movie of his that I have seen I have liked. Only sixteen movies of which at least ten movies that range from very good to classic. Seems very unrealistic, doesn't it? Prior to this I had watched six of his films and now have told myself that to expect his other movies to be great may lead to disappointment. The last couple of movies that I have seen of his I started with average expectations. In my opinion 'Barry Lyndon' is better than a good film.

1. I don't think Kubrick has repeated his lead actors in any film. Has he? So that's one thing I look forward to in Kubrick's films. New faces who will give a good performances. Ryan O'Neal and the actor playing his stepson give decent acting performances.

2. If there is one director who can handle any genre of cinema it has to be Stanley Kubrick. Is there anyone else? He has done sci-fi, heist, ultra-violence, war, court-room drama, sex, horror.......In as few as sixteen films he has covered a broad spectrum.

3. The story of 'Barry Lyndon' although not different it is not totally predictable. It seems to slow down a little in the second half but the final duel covers up for this. We can see the end coming, in fact even predict good portions of it. Redmond Barry is transformed in this movie. We can all see it coming after an hour into the film just because we know where this transformation is going.

4. But 'Barry Lyndon' is not about the story as much as it is about how it is told. Personally, I like the first half, or 'Part 1', where Redmond Barry runs away from home and joins the war. Then he is captured by the Prussians and fights his own people! I kept telling myself this is the story of a coward, I even found the first half funny. The scene where Barry breaks down in front of The Chavalier to me was damn funny. I seriously thought this was a comedy below the surface of what is known as a period film. But then Barry Lyndon's ill-treatment of his stepson sets up the final act.

5. The character of Barry is very interesting to me. The early scenes show him very shy and in love. But suddenly he is transformed when he sees a pal die in war. After that he is a plain opportunist. In many ways this is an extra-ordinary story. It is the story of a con-man, an impostor, which is familiar to regular Bollywood followers. This is where Stanley Kubrick steps in and makes 'Barry Lyndon' what it is.

6. I loved the music in this film. This was funny to me too. During times of war and scenes of death the music that was playing sounded more like a nursery rhyme to me! Unbelievable as it may seem such were my thoughts in the scenes of war. That does not mean I didn't like the music.

7. Finally, I have a problem with the duel. Beautifully shot! I loved the location and the birds flying around. The sound mixing or editing or whatever it is called was superb. I am now starting to realise how sounds create an atmosphere and tension. At moments of tension it happens to me when I start hearing every small sound. I got the same feeling here. Coming back to my problem with this duel. Being the opportunist that Barry has been all through the film I could not see the reason for him to spare his stepson. Why does he let his son live? It seemed out of character to me. Maybe more thought and another viewing will clarify this but I don't have the patience for it right now.

8. Oh! I liked the performance Frank Middlemass. He is not there for more than a minute but it was a good strong performance. I guess the lines given to him were to so strong it seemed he acted well.

CONCLUSION: Engaging first half, steady second half, good performances by those mentioned, the final duel, great music and Kubrick's touch make this worth a watch.

RATING: 3.5/5